• About Pursuit Magazine
  • Sign Up for Updates
  • Contact Us
  • Write For Us
facebook
twitter
google_plus
  • The Business
    • Investigation
    • Security
    • Bail Enforcement
    • Service of Process
    • Skip Trace
  • The Life
    • Profiles
    • Culture
    • Inquisitor
    • Investigator’s Notebook
    • Pocket Litter
  • The Pitch
    • Social Media
    • Marketing
    • Branding
    • Content Marketing
    • Old School
  • The Repository
    • Continuing Education
    • State Laws
    • Search Engines
The magazine of professional investigators

Weekly Briefing 030920

09 Mar 2020
Hal Humphreys
Off
criminal defense investigation, private investigator

“How can you defend criminals?”

I get that question all the time — from the general public, and even from other private investigators. I may have even had similar thoughts, back in the day, before I waded neck-deep into the world of criminal defense investigations. Before I worked several trials (including murder cases and post-conviction work) and got to know an incredible cadre of hard-fighting defense attorneys — and the people they defend.

I think about that question differently now. There are several good answers, including the uber-obvious: “Innocent until proven guilty.” But beyond that, I’ve come to know quite a few so-called “criminals.” Defined as: people who’ve been convicted of serious crimes. Folks who, in some cases, have done great harm to others and ruined lives, including their own. I offer no excuses for their actions, but I can’t write them off as simply “criminals,” defined solely by the worst thing they ever did.

But also, there’s this: sometimes, the prosecution overreaches. That’s what I believe happened in a trial I worked earlier this month: prosecutors told one story about our client, and the evidence, as I saw it, told another. Sometimes, there really is a best answer, a punishment that fits the crime. But the only way to have any hope of arriving at that best answer is to pit prosecution against defense and let them duke it out … hard.

Of course, that only works if the scales aren’t tipped heavily in favor of one side or the other.

That’s just my take. Later this week, I’ll get another take — from David Guinn, a Lubbock defense attorney whom I respect mightily. We’ll talk about why criminal defense work matters, the vital role it plays in a functioning criminal justice system, and why we find the work so rewarding. We’ll post that audio and transcript here at PursuitMag in the next few days.

In the meantime, here’s the weekly briefing video:

Recent Comments

About the Author
Hal Humphreys is executive editor of Pursuit Magazine and founder/lead investigator of [FIND] Investigations, a PI agency in Nashville, TN. In his spare time, he's also a writer, radio producer, hiker, and fly fisherman. Visit his website at findinvestigations.com or follow him on Twitter: @FINDPI
PI Education 300×250

From the Editor

Editor's Message 4.5.21: Leadership Takes Practice

05 Apr 2021
No Responses.
Investigator Marketing

Recent Post

10 Qualities of Effective Leadership

08 Apr 2021
No Responses.

Editor's Message 4.5.21: Leadership Takes Practice

05 Apr 2021
No Responses.

About Pursuit Magazine

  • About Pursuit Magazine
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy and Terms of Use
  • Submit Articles

Pursuit Magazine – The magazine of professional investigators

Masthead

Publisher – Jim McLeod 
Executive Editor – Hal Humphreys
Managing Editor – Kim Green
Advertising – Stephanie Mitchell
Web Master – Ruben Roel

Contributors & Industry Experts

The Files